Who Do You Say That I Am? by Cornelius Van Til

by Cornelius Van Til
Presbyterian and Reformed, 1975. 106 pp.
A concise overview of the history of philosophy in relationship to the claims of Christ. These lectures also exist in audio tape form.


Ancient Man Replies
A. Who Blasphemes, Jesus or the Pharisees?
B. Stephen the Martyr
C. The Risen Lord Appears to Paul
D. Saul the Persecutor Becomes Paul the Apostle
     1. Paul at Lystra
     2. Paul and the Greek Philosophers
E. Paul’s World-Wide Mission
     1. Paul at Athens—the Biblical Framework of Thought
          a. All Men are Covenant-Breakers in Adam
          b. The Resurrection Indicates the Coming Judgment
F. The Greek Paideia
     1. Behold the Man: Socrates
     2. Werner Jaeger on the Greek Paideia
          a. (Arete)
          b. The Search for a Divine Center: Socrates
          c. The Contrast Between the Greek and the Christian Paideia
     3. Platonic Idealism
     4. Aristotle’s Form-Matter Scheme
Medieval Man Replies
A. Plotinus and Augustine
     1. Plotinus and the Scale of Being
B. Augustine and the City of God
C. From Augustine to Thomas Aquinas
     1. Negative Theology—Pseudo-Dionysius
     2. Natural Theology
     3. Mystical Theology
D. Gilson’s Argument for the Medieval Synthesis
     1. Necessity—The Parmenidean Principle of Continuity
          a. A Christian Philosophy
     2. Contingency—The Heraclitean Principle of Discontinuity
E. Degrees of Knowledge
     1. Thomas Aquinas as the Medieval Man—Par Excellence
F. Degrees of Love
G. The Total Picture
H. The Substantial Unity of Man
I. Conclusion
Modern Man Replies
A. Renaissance Man Replies
     1. Renaissance Man vs. Reformation Man
          a. Modern Science
     2. Renaissance Man’s Idea of Himself
          a. Nicolas Cusanus
          b. Francis Bacon
     3. Reformation Man’s Idea of Himself
          a. Martin Luther vs. Boehme
          b. Descartes vs. Calvin
B. Immanuel Kant and the Principle of Inwardness
C. Post-Kantian Man Replies
     1. The Post-Kantian Theologian—Karl Barth Replies
     2. The Post-Kantian Scientist—Teilhard de Chardin Replies
     3. The Post-Kantian Philosopher—Robert Collingwood Replies
D. The Modern Church Replies—The Congress of 2000
     1. The Confession of 1967
     2. Lutherans and Calvinists
     3. The Protestant Principle and the Roman Catholic Principle
     4. The Christian Principle and the Jewish Principle
     5. The Thirty-Eighth Parallel


” ’But who do you say that I am?’ asked Jesus. Ancient man replied, ’You are a mere man. ’ Medieval man answered, ’You are a man-God. ’ Modern man responds, ’You are Authentic Man.’ There has never been a time when the question of the identity of Jesus of Nazareth was so important as it is today. For example, was He the self-attesting Christ of the historic Protestant confessions; or is He, rather, the ’Christ-Event’ of post-Kantian philosophy and theology? The present booklet gives the writer’s reasons for believing Him to be not the latter but the former. If one would reject the genuine, self-attesting Christ of Scripture, he must do so, unavoidably, in terms of the self-attesting man. But the very existence of the latter presupposes, unavoidably, the self-attesting Christ; thus, to deny the former’s claim is self-stultifying.”-from the Preface



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s